What she thought was the end of her career, and what came after
Let's call her Maya. She's built from pieces of several women, so she doesn't correspond to any actual member or client. She is 55, serves as chief operating officer, and is forty minutes into a board session that is going poorly. Her voice catches on the word "layoffs," and her eyes well up.
The layoffs aren't truly what sets it off. It's the eleven months behind them: a father in hospice, alarm clocks set for 4 a.m., and a director across the table who has just asked, for the third time, whether operations "has a grip on this." She does have a grip on it. Her grip on it has lasted so long her hands hurt.
A dozen people have their attention locked on her. Before anyone reaches for a comforting phrase, she has roughly four seconds, and any such comfort would only deepen the problem. What she chooses to do in those four seconds is the real decision.
Option one. Apologize and push through
Taking a sip of water, she murmurs, "Sorry, one moment," and returns her attention to the screen. The trouble with apologizing is that it frames the tears as an error, and that framing hands the room a reason to view them the same way. For the next week she keeps replaying the meeting, unsure what the chairman made of an apology she gave before she had even understood what was happening.
Option two. Call a ten-minute break
Looking up, she announces, "Let's take ten," and walks out the door. A pause that the woman who just cried has requested is one that everyone reads as obvious, and when she comes back, the room has spent ten minutes discussing her. The upside is genuine. When she comes back, she is steady and finishes the meeting in her own way.
Option three. Name it and continue
"This has been a rough year for this team, and you can see it in the numbers," she says. "We are going to keep moving forward." She offers no apology and no justification, just one clear line. The cost is that a few directors may recall that single line far more vividly than any of the charts. The benefit is that she has named what everyone in the room already saw, before anyone else had the chance to define it for her.
What experienced executives suggest
Women who have run Pittsburgh-area boardrooms for years are far less alarmed by this than Lydia is. Crying is rarely what sinks a presenter; it is the apology that does the damage. People in a room tend to take their cues from whoever is holding the moment. If you handle it as a disaster, the audience will treat it as one too. If you handle it as an ordinary event, most of the audience will treat it that way as well. There is also a less comfortable point worth raising. The standard is not even. When a man gets emotional about layoffs, people call it "human," but when a woman does, they call it "emotional," and research on likability has repeatedly shown that the same conduct draws different labels depending on who performs it. That isn't a reason to hide. It argues for shaping how the moment is interpreted.
Among 7,500 women surveyed by Deloitte in 2025, 29% rated their mental health as poor. Nobody in that boardroom is protected from this. Some of them have stood where Lydia is standing.
The choice made
In the composite case, Lydia opts for Option C. As the meeting ends, the chairman remarks before the whole group, "That was the most candid update this board has received in a year," and asks the director who had the questions to send them in writing. It surprises her. It shouldn't have. Most board chairs have endured far worse, and what stays with them is who kept composed and kept going.
The real question is whether you can deliver the sentence without an apology hidden inside it. If you can, say it. If you're not ready for that, take the break.
Survey
Out of options A, B, and C in Pittsburgh, which one would you have gone with? Send your letter to the Pittsburgh chapter and we will publish the results next month. If you have ever stood where Lydia stood, we'd welcome your account.