A 9-question test, and why the answer changes everything you do next
Your manager claimed your analysis in front of the CEO on Monday, then called you by the wrong name in front of a vendor on Wednesday. Somewhere around Friday, after the fourth article on narcissism in a row, you notice that each description fits the man you report to in Pittsburgh. Those same articles also describe a worn-out, recently promoted manager whom no one ever trained to lead a team. The distinction is important, since one of these bosses can be worked with and the other has to be endured.
People usually respond by diagnosing the boss and then acting as though the diagnosis were a strategy. Still, sorting him into a category rarely gives you a next step, which is why the label so often leaves people stuck. If he is simply inexperienced, treating him as a narcissist makes you wary of someone who might have been willing to help. If he is in fact a narcissist, assuming he is just a green manager could leave you waiting a full year for a change that never arrives.
Here, then, is a test: nine questions, posed through five ordinary situations. A boss who is weak at the job will stumble, improve a bit, and then forget. Speaking up tends to draw punishment from a narcissist.
1. The credit goes missing
Your instinct is to say, "You know I did that work."
Stronger phrasing would be, "Happy the CEO responded well to it." Next phase, I'd like to take her through my section myself."
Three questions tell you what to look for. Does he agree? Does the agreement survive until the meeting arrives? Without anyone asking, does he name you when credit comes up? A new manager who agrees and then forgets usually responds well to a short reminder. A narcissist says yes, then finds a reason you shouldn't be in the room.
2. Suppose you arrive with a problem that he caused.
The reflex is to say, "This happened because you moved the deadline."
Better still, "The deadline moved, costing us a full week." Here is what I need to get it back."
Two questions will show you how he responds. Does he move straight to the fix, or does he start assigning blame? Does the talk remain about the work itself? An inexperienced manager tends to get rattled first and grateful later. A narcissist grows cold, and the lost week gets recast as time you supposedly wasted.
3. You ask for something small
The pull is to request nothing at all, because asking feels dangerous.
A stronger one: "I'd like Friday for the leadership workshop. The deliverables are covered."
Keep an eye on two questions that matter here in Western Pennsylvania. Does he treat your request as something useful to know, or as evidence you're against him? Does a cost surface later that nobody bothers to name? Ineffective managers just lose track of what they promised. Narcissists keep a running tab.
4. You disagree in a meeting, respectfully
The temptation is to keep quiet until speaking feels safe.
Something like, "My view is a bit different. May I give the other side in two minutes?"
One question is what to watch for here. How does the day feel to you once the Pittsburgh meeting adjourns? A manager who is simply struggling may sulk for an hour and move on. A narcissist quietly builds a case against you, and your next review ends up describing you as "not a team player."
5. Something goes well without him
Your go-to line might be, "The client meeting went great. You didn't miss anything."
A sharper version is, "The client approved it. What's your take on the next step?"
What to watch for: the most important single question. Can he feel happy for your win when he was never in the room for it? An inexperienced manager usually can. A narcissist can't, and you will feel the chill for a week.
The logic that ties these five together
Notice how his replies land. If he mainly stumbles and forgets, he is likely just weak at the job, and written follow-ups plus patience can help you manage upward. If he mostly punishes, stop hoping for change, document everything, and start working through what leaving would cost and gain you. Tulshyan and Burey, writing in HBR, contended that the imposter label pins a systemic problem on one person. A bad boss performs much the same move. Your personality isn't where the breakdown lies.
Pass this along to the friend who keeps wondering whether she's the cause. It isn't.