A scorecard for women who stopped checking years ago
Conventional wisdom on this only works so far. If you truly enjoy your job, pay becomes a secondary concern. A supportive manager, meaningful work and a team you can rely on often count for more than a few extra percentage points, and chasing every dollar tends to wear people down. Plenty of women in the Pittsburgh region who jumped ship for a 15% bump now find themselves unhappy, only at a higher salary.
Here is the counterpoint: loving your job is precisely when you are most likely to be underpaid, because the people deciding your pay can see how little you push.
1. Loyalty is priced in
Your salary reflects the market, not your merit. Your salary is set by the expense of finding someone to fill your seat, then nudged by the odds that you would leave if underpaid. A 2025 report from McKinsey and LeanIn found that only 54% of companies treat women's advancement as a high priority, and the ones that don't are unlikely to volunteer a fix. Three signs you are in this group: you have not had a single outside conversation in three years, every raise you've received has been the standard percentage, and no one has ever countered an offer for you because you never gave them a reason to.
2. The work grew and the number did not
In the book The No Club, researchers reported that one professional-services firm had women putting in about 200 extra hours annually on work that earns no promotion credit, while being tapped for it roughly half again as often as men. A passion for the work makes it simple to agree to extra tasks. Three signs: your scope has expanded without a title change, you are training colleagues you suspect earn more than you do, and planning, note-taking and offsite logistics keep landing on your desk while no one tracks them.
3. The market moved while you were busy
Posted salary ranges are now required in a growing number of states, so market data is visible to anyone who takes the time to look, and you have not. Watch for three warning signals: a colleague at your rank in Greensburg or Washington came in on a higher salary, a headhunter named a number that surprised you, or you cannot name the pay range for your position, much less your place inside it.
Where the traditional counsel still holds true
Do not give up work you enjoy over a 5% difference. That counsel turns harmful only when it stops you from ever looking at the numbers. Caring about your work and understanding its market value can coexist comfortably. Women who get paid fairly in jobs they love are usually the ones who kept their number current while they stayed put.
What to do next
Score yourself against the nine signs. Three or fewer, and you are probably fine; check once a year. Four to six, and your pay is drifting; spend thirty minutes this week on a market check, pulling three posted ranges for your title in the Pittsburgh metro and noting the midpoint. Seven or more, and you are effectively subsidizing your employer, and affection for the job is not a line item on a payroll.
Afterward, raise a single calm question during your regular one-on-one with your manager, such as: "I would like to understand where I fall in the salary range for my level, and what it would take to get to the midpoint." Make clear you are not signaling a plan to resign. You are simply requesting clarity on compensation, and a manager who deflects has already revealed something useful.
Which of the nine signs did you find in your own case?